Monty Don Fires back at Unexpected Criticism Over Garden Post

Monty Don, one of Britain’s most beloved gardening experts, has long been admired for his thoughtful insights and calming presence on BBC’s Gardeners’ World. Over the years, his knowledge and passion for plants have earned him a loyal following, both on-screen and online. With more than 1.3 million Instagram followers, Monty often gives fans a peek into his lush cottage garden in Herefordshire — a garden that’s become something of a national treasure in its own right.

Yet even for someone as respected as Monty, not every post earns applause.

Don’s Herefordshire garden, with its winding paths, colorful blooms, and tranquil corners, is a visual delight for gardening fans across the world. His regular updates on seasonal changes, planting advice, and even candid moments with his dog have made his Instagram account a peaceful retreat for nature lovers.

His ability to blend natural beauty with thoughtful design has made his garden not just a personal space, but a public inspiration.

But even the most serene gardens can spark debate.

Earlier today, Monty shared a series of images from his garden, including two tall trees that sparked unexpected backlash. The trees — striking and architectural — immediately caught the attention of followers. But instead of praise, many voiced concern.

Some fans argued that the trees, which they believed to be conifers, looked “too formal” and disrupted the soft, natural look of Monty’s cottage-style garden. One commenter said, “I love your gardens—but not this one. The conifers look so out of place, especially with the tops being horizontal and not leaving their standard shape.” Another wrote, “Agree about the trees, find them very off-putting. The rest is really beautiful.”

One follower even said the trees made the garden look like a “show garden… something that shouldn’t be enjoyed.”

In true Monty Don fashion, the gardening guru didn’t stay silent — but he didn’t lash out either. Instead, he offered a calm, thoughtful response.

First, he corrected the assumption that the trees were conifers. He explained they were actually Irish yews, a tree often chosen for its vertical structure and formal elegance. Irish yews are frequently used in garden design to create focal points or to add a sense of balance among more free-flowing plantings.

Monty replied, “Each to their own… and not conifers but Irish yews looking lovely with their flat tops!”

His reply was simple but firm, a reminder that gardening, like art, is subjective — and that even experts make bold choices that may not please everyone.

While some remained unconvinced, many others rushed to Monty’s defense. They praised his expertise and reminded critics that gardening is a creative expression. One follower wrote, “Monty has years of experience. If anyone can pull this off, it’s him.”

Others noted that gardens evolve — and what might seem odd today could look stunning once other seasonal elements grow in.

This small dust-up reveals something deeper about the gardening community. For many, gardens are deeply personal. Cottage garden enthusiasts, in particular, have strong feelings about what “fits” and what doesn’t. But Monty’s experience shows that even the most established styles can leave room for experimentation and surprise.

At the end of the day, Monty Don continues to teach — not just about plants, but about grace under pressure and staying true to one’s vision. His garden, like his legacy, will keep growing.